Spiritual Indifference Is Not Neutral Ground With God
From the sermon preached on March 22, 2026
Spiritual indifference — the quiet condition of not caring about God anymore — is not a neutral state. According to Zechariah chapter 5, it is a condition under active divine judgment. This post unpacks a recent Mosaic Boston sermon on two of the strangest visions in all of scripture: a flying scroll and a woman in a basket. Both communicate the same urgent truth: there is no safe middle ground between God's blessing and God's curse, and indifference is not the absence of a choice.
The sermon wasn't pitched as an easy Sunday. Pastor Andy Hoot opened by admitting that the worst pastoral conversations he has aren't with people who are in obvious, blatant sin — they're with people who simply don't care anymore. Give him the couple fighting in his office, the young disciple who joined every ministry at once and blew everything up, even the person with the most embarrassing confession. Those he can work with. But a person who sits across from him and says, "I just don't feel anything anymore" — that's the conversation that makes him tremble. Because the tools that work on a rebellious heart — scripture, honest confrontation, the weight of the Gospel — slide right off a numb one. And numbness, Pastor Andy argued, is not just a church problem. It is a pandemic running through the entire city of Boston, showing up as the next relationship, the next purchase, the next anything that might finally produce a feeling.
Zechariah chapter 5 is God's direct word into that condition.
What Does the Flying Scroll in Zechariah 5 Actually Mean?
The prophet Zechariah, whose name literally means "the Lord remembers," receives his sixth vision in chapter 5 — and it is not comforting. He lifts his eyes and sees a massive scroll flying through the air. Not a banner behind a small plane. A scroll the size of a building: thirty feet long, fifteen feet wide, forty times larger than any ordinary scroll of the ancient world. Those dimensions were not arbitrary. First Kings 6:3 tells us they match precisely the measurements of Solomon's portico — the porch of the Jerusalem temple where God's law was publicly read to his people — and the holy of holies, where the ark of the covenant was kept. The people of Zechariah's day were actively rebuilding the temple. They would have recognized those numbers immediately.
The message of the scroll's size is unmistakable: this judgment is coming from the holy presence of God himself. It is written on both sides — just as the tablets of stone Moses carried down from Mount Sinai were written on both sides — covering the whole law. One side addresses theft, representing the commandments governing human relationships. The other side addresses false swearing in God's name, representing the commandments governing our relationship to God. Together they indict the people for failing to love God and failing to love neighbor — the two great commandments Christ would later say summarize everything. The scroll announces that those who break covenant will be "cleaned out," a word the text also translates as "banished."
What makes this especially unsettling is the nature of banishment. It doesn't feel like a catastrophe from the inside. The further a person drifts from God, the more the conscience gets seared, and the less that distance registers as loss. As the Apostle Paul writes in Romans 1:18, the wrath of God is revealed against all ungodliness and unrighteousness — not just dramatic rebellion, but the quiet, daily kind.
Today's step: Sit with Deuteronomy 27–28 or Leviticus 26 and read the covenant terms straight. The blessings are real. So are the curses. Let the weight of those chapters do its work before you move on.
Why Does Materialism Show Up as Spiritual Rebellion in This Passage?
The second vision in Zechariah 5 shifts from the sweeping image of the flying scroll to something stranger and more personal. An angel directs Zechariah's attention to a large basket — a commercial measuring container, the kind used at market — moving across the landscape. Inside it, sealed under a seventy-five-pound lead cover, is a woman. The angel identifies her plainly: "This is wickedness." Two other women, whose wings are filled with the Hebrew word ruach — wind, breath, spirit — lift the basket and carry it to the land of Shinar, another name for Babylon, where a temple will be built for it.
The basket itself is the sermon's sharpest detail. It is a commercial object. The wickedness it represents is not some abstract theological category — it is the idolatry of material comfort, the same drift the prophet Haggai diagnosed when he told the returned exiles: "Is it a time for you to live in your paneled houses while my house lies in ruins?" (Haggai 1:4). The people freed from Babylon had brought Babylon back with them inside their own desires. They weren't carving wooden idols. They were doing something more familiar: convincing themselves that one more renovation, one more upgrade, one more comfortable arrangement of their circumstances would finally satisfy. Zechariah calls that idolatry. And he says it belongs in Babylon, not in Jerusalem.
The vision ends with wickedness being carried back to where it came from and set on its base in an idol temple. The Spirit of God, in an act of both judgment and mercy, removes from the holy city what refuses to be surrendered. The haunting implication is this: God does not permanently cohabit with what his people will not release.
Today's step: Name one area where comfort has become a substitute for obedience. Write it down. Not to manufacture guilt — but to give it a name, which is the beginning of releasing it.
How Does Christ Bear the Curse That Zechariah Describes?
This is where the sermon refuses to leave the bad news sitting without an answer — but the answer is not what you might expect. The people of Zechariah's day received the warning. They finished a diminished temple, failed to sustain it, and drifted back into the patterns the prophet Malachi would diagnose in the very next book of the Old Testament. No one proved to be holy enough to build what God actually wanted. The warning, in that sense, was not enough.
The sermon closes with a single, startling observation: Christ fulfilled the visions of Zechariah 5 in his own body. He was "cleaned out from the land" — banished, not by his own wickedness but by ours. He hung between heaven and earth. He was forsaken by both man and God, crying out "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?" — and the answer to that cry is exactly what the visions in Zechariah 5 picture. The great lead weight of human wickedness was pressed down upon him. He was sent to Babylon, as it were, so that we would not have to be. He was made wickedness, as the Apostle Paul writes in 2 Corinthians, so that we might become the righteousness of God.
Second Timothy 2:20–21 offers the practical response to that grace: "If anyone cleanses himself from what is dishonorable, he will be a vessel for honorable use, set apart as holy, useful to the master of the house, ready for every good work." This is not a moralism. It is a response — not attempting to earn what Christ already purchased, but living like someone who has actually received it.
Today's step: When the guilt surfaces — and this sermon will surface it — don't bury it. Name it out loud in prayer. Look to Christ, who bore it. Then ask: what area of my life have I not yet submitted to him?
Three Signs Spiritual Indifference May Already Be at Work
1. You've stopped sensing conviction
What it means: The conscience does not suddenly go silent. It gets seared gradually, each compromise making the next one easier to justify. The absence of conviction is not peace — it is the earliest sign that banishment may be underway.
What Zechariah says: The flying scroll enters the house and "remains" there — the judgment is not a single blow but a sustained, compounding presence.
2. You're chasing the next thing to feel something
What it means: The compulsive shopper, the person who cycles through relationships looking for the one that finally lands, the professional who moves from goal to goal without satisfaction — these are not fundamentally different from the returned exiles fixated on their houses. They are all trying to manufacture feeling in the absence of God.
What Zechariah says: The basket is a commercial object. The idolatry is not theological — it is practical, everyday, and ordinary.
3. You've settled for a comfortable arrangement instead of obedience
What it means: The couple who agreed to just coexist. The churchgoer who stopped caring about the work. The professional who rationalized that their career was enough. Haggai 1:4 names it precisely: living in paneled houses while the temple sits in ruins.
What Zechariah says: There is no neutral ground. The covenant comes with blessing and with curse. Indifference is a choice — it just doesn't feel like one.
A Word to Anyone Asking This in Brookline or Greater Boston
Boston is not an easy city to be spiritually alive in. It is dense, demanding, and deeply secular — and those features tend to reward the kind of person who keeps their interior life managed and private. The Longwood Medical Area, the universities, the professional culture of the city all train people to be high-functioning, which is not the same thing as not being numb. Mosaic Boston was planted in Brookline in 2011 precisely because the city has a lot of church buildings and very few places where someone can walk in, not check their mind at the door, and encounter a Gospel that takes the bad news seriously enough to make the good news mean something. If you've been feeling the weight of what this post describes — the flatness, the distance, the sense that faith used to mean something and doesn't anymore — that's worth investigating. There's no pressure here, just an open door.
Numb Is Not Forever — But It Does Require a Response
Zechariah 5 does not end in despair. It ends with a picture of the Spirit of God actively at work — lifting, carrying, cleansing — because God refuses to be indifferent to his people even when they are indifferent to him. Christ bore the full weight of the curse so that the numb could be made alive again. The answer to spiritual indifference is not trying harder. It is looking, honestly and directly, at what Christ carried — and letting that actually land.
Frequently Asked Questions
-
Spiritual indifference describes a condition in which a person who has known God — or professed to — stops caring about him, his word, or his call on their life. In Zechariah 5, it is treated not as a neutral resting state but as an active drift away from covenant faithfulness. The flying scroll vision makes clear that indifference, left unaddressed, carries the same covenant consequences as open rebellion.
-
According to Zechariah 5, God deals with spiritual indifference through two forms of response: mercy offered repeatedly in the earlier chapters of the book, and judgment pictured in the flying scroll and the woman in the basket. The goal of the judgment is not destruction but awakening — the visions exist to shake people out of numbness before the consequences compound further.
-
This is one of the harder questions in Christian theology, and the sermon engages it honestly. The position held at Mosaic Boston is that true believers persevere — but that perseverance looks like ongoing repentance and pursuit of holiness, not passive presumption on past grace. Hebrews 10:26–31, cited in the sermon, warns that those who go on sinning deliberately after receiving knowledge of the truth face a fearful expectation of judgment. The sermon's point is not to produce anxiety but to produce the kind of serious self-examination that drives a person back to Christ.
-
The sermon identifies several: the absence of conviction (a seared conscience that no longer registers sin as sin), a compulsive chase after experiences or things to produce feeling, and a settled comfort with a life organized around personal ease rather than obedience. Crucially, Pastor Andy Hoot notes that these signs can feel like peace from the inside — which is precisely what makes them dangerous.
-
The sermon offers a deliberately un-formulaic answer. It begins with honesty: name the numbness, don't excuse it. Then bring it to scripture, not as a technique but as the word that carries authority no preacher has on their own. And then look specifically to Christ — who bore the curse of banishment in his own body — and ask what areas of life have not yet been submitted to him.